Dave Garagiola

Broker / Owner, Agent

NextHome Realty Premier Properties

About Dave Garagiola

David Garagiola is a licensed REALTOR® and Broker Owner with NextHome Realty Premier Properties, serving Monmouth, Ocean, Middlesex, and Mercer Counties in New Jersey.  Since being licensed in 2013, David and Michelle Garagiola have sold over $66m million in closed sales volume and 239 successfully completed transactions.  His professionalism, deep community knowledge, and proven results make him a trusted advisor for clients across Howell, Freehold, Jackson, Brick, Toms River, and the surrounding areas.

Experience & Recognition:  Over his career, David and Michelle have earned recognitions through the New Jersey REALTORS® Circle of Excellence (2016-2024), Premier Sales Award Winners in 2021-2024, and their Office has received the Diamond Pinnacle Award with NextHome Realty in 2023 and 2024. 

They have been featured as a verified top agent on FastExpert along with verified client reviews on Zillow, Realtor.com, Reach150, and FastExpert, all which provides measurable proof of client satisfaction and consistent performance in the competitive Monmouth–Ocean market.

Areas of Expertise:  David and Michelle specialize in traditional sales, luxury real estate, short sales, and probate properties, bringing a calm, strategic approach to even the most complex transactions. Whether representing first-time buyers, sellers upgrading to their next home, or families navigating estate sales, he focuses on transparency, communication, and results.

Markets Served:   David serves the key New Jersey communities of Howell, Freehold, Jackson, Brick, Toms River, Manalapan, and Marlboro along with all the surrounding areas, offering local insight into schools, neighborhoods, and current market conditions.

Connect:  To learn more about working with David Garagiola and NextHome Realty Premier Properties, visit his profiles on Zillow, FastExpert, Realtor.com, or Reach150, or contact him directly for personalized market guidance in buying or selling your #NextHome.

Latest Blog Posts

Monmouth County Market Pulse July 2026

The July 2026 Monmouth Pivot: Why Rising Inventory and the '21-Day Sprint' Define the New Coastal Standard1. Introduction: The Coastal Market ShiftSearching for a home in Monmouth County has long

Read More

The $868,000 Surge: 4 Surprising Truths About the Morganville Housing Market Right Now

The $868,000 Surge: 4 Surprising Truths About the Morganville Housing Market Right NowImagine sitting at a red light on Route 9, watching the steady stream of commuters heading toward the city, and

Read More

NextHome Insight: Five Surprising Realities of Life in Howell’s 07731

NextHome Insight: Five Surprising Realities of Life in Howell’s 077311. The Suburban EnigmaThe "average" American suburb is often stereotyped as a transient collection of cookie-cutter homes,

Read More